It’s been with no little excitement that i’ve watched the Curiosity Rover landing on Mars this week. Astronomy has been a back-burner interest of mine since i was a boy and, not surprisingly, i’ve been especially fond of the sound recordings produced by NASA from the data received by Voyagers I and II as they’ve travelled through and beyond the solar system. So i was intrigued last year to see an independent release of something called Voyager: Sounds of the Cosmos, a large-scale compilation of these NASA recordings, made available in three versions of increasing length, titled ‘Grand Tour Edition’, ‘Standard Edition’ and ‘Legacy Edition’ respectively. However, as i’ve spent more time with it, i couldn’t shake the feeling i’d heard these before, so i did some elementary investigating. It turns out—and the compiler, one Philip Graham (aka RazorEye), admits this on the Wikipedia page—that the compilation is a bootleg of earlier NASA releases, some of which are still readily available. However, new track titles have been invented and there’s also a bit of duplicity and misguidedness going on, so for the benefit of others who love these sounds as much as i do, i thought i’d just flag up the facts regarding this material, in order to make an informed choice possible.
The compilation draws on just two primary sources for all of its audio. The first is the 5-hour album Nasa Voyager Space Sounds, originally released in 1992 on a series of CDs in collaboration with Dr Jeffrey D. Thompson. These CDs are long out of print, but NASA has reissued the complete album as a digital download, currently available very cheaply from both iTunes and Amazon. The second source is the 2½-hour 5-CD set Symphonies of the Planets, originally released back in 1990 and also out of print (and not, to date, reissued). Therefore, anyone who has these albums can ignore the Voyager: Sounds of the Cosmos compilation, as it contains exactly the same material. i mentioned duplicity; in addition, some of the audio contained in the compilation pointlessly duplicates material heard elsewhere, presumably in the hope that, due to the nebulous nature of these sounds, no-one would notice. If that wasn’t ridiculous enough, the Wikipedia page (clearly written by the compiler himself), states “Most of the files were reduced of quality [sic] from multiple usage, and was restored to full recording quality using Audacity” – demonstrating lamentable ignorance about the nature of audio.
The compiler is, it seems, currently engaged in unleashing a third re-hash of this material, and the bungling way he’s been going about it can be witnessed in the recently released ‘Grand Tour’ edition, some tracks of which were obviously purchased recently on iTunes, clearly showing the purchaser’s name and email address. (There are ways and ways of putting out a bootleg, but this isn’t one of them.) Anyway, below is a table showing the complete list of tracks from the second issue of the Legacy Edition, showing the origin of each track (for visual proof, go here – which also proves not one iota of remastering has been done); and below that, links to copies of all five original, out-of-print Symphonies of the Planets albums, all in far higher resolution than the execrable Voyager: Sounds of the Cosmos compilation. As for the remaining tracks, go to iTunes or Amazon; for sounds as wonderfully rich and detailed as these, you’ll be much better off.
|1||Earth (Launch)||‘Nasa – Song of Earth’, track 7 from Nasa Voyager Space Sounds|
|2||Earth (Echoes)||‘Nasa – Voice of Earth’, track 10 from Nasa Voyager Space Sounds|
|3||Jupiter (Bow Shock)||Symphonies of the Planets 4|
|4||Jupiter (Closest Approach)||‘Nasa – Jupiter’, track 1 from Nasa Voyager Space Sounds|
|5||Jupiter (Io Flyby)||‘Nasa – Sphere of Io’, track 8 from Nasa Voyager Space Sounds|
|6||Saturn (Closest Approach)||‘Nasa – Saturn’, track 6 from Nasa Voyager Space Sounds|
|7||Saturn (Rings)||Symphonies of the Planets 2|
|8||Saturn (Voyager 1 Ring Crossing)||An exact duplicate of Track 7, faded out after 21’56”|
|9||Saturn (Voyager 2 Full Flyby)||‘Nasa – Saturn’s Rings’, track 5 from Nasa Voyager Space Sounds|
|10||Uranus (Bow Shock)||‘Nasa – Uranus’, track 9 from Nasa Voyager Space Sounds|
|11||Uranus (Approach)||Tracks 11-14 are exact duplicates of Track 15, which has simply been cut into four pieces with fades in & out|
|12||Uranus (Crossing The Rings Pt.1)|
|13||Uranus (Crossing The Rings Pt.2)|
|14||Uranus (Crossing The Rings Pt.3)|
|15||Uranus (Echoes Of The Rings)||Symphonies of the Planets 1|
|16||Uranus (Miranda)||‘Nasa – Miranda’, track 2 from Nasa Voyager Space Sounds|
|17||Uranus (Echoes Of Uranus)||‘Nasa – Rings of Uranus’, track 4 from Nasa Voyager Space Sounds|
|18||Neptune (Closest Approach)||‘Nasa – Neptune’, track 3 from Nasa Voyager Space Sounds|
|19||Neptune (Out of the Ecliptic)||Symphonies of the Planets 3|
|20||Unspecified 1||An exact duplicate of Track 9, faded out after 9’59”|
|21||Unspecified 2||Symphonies of the Planets 5|