Two concerts yesterday, on what had punningly come to be known as “Frey-day”, afforded the opportunity to spend considerably more time with the music of Jürg Frey. i’ve been wrangling with how the word ‘ascetic’ sits with respect to Frey’s music. It’s not, i believe, music wearing a hairshirt, but the more i’ve heard of it this week, the more i’ve felt as though i am—which in turn has to make one question seriously what is happening and to what end. This feeling was particularly acute at the midday concert of four of Frey’s compositions, given by Ensemble Grizzana—a new group comprising soloists Mira Benjamin, Richard Craig, Emma Richards, Philip Thomas and Anton Lukoszevieze along with Frey himself. Returning to my String Quartet No. 2 trekking metaphor—forever progressing at a consistent, unstoppable speed—their performance of Fragile Balance resembled a group of walkers taking it in turns to suggest where their communal next step should be taken, followed by everybody taking it. And so on. Guided by a score consisting of “lists of single sounds and little motifs”, aurally this was not a work where a sense of journey was important—after all, if a journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step, this particular journey would likely take a thousand years—but rather the act of travelling. While this sounds like a concrete reading of what was happening, it should be clear from the description that everything about it was not merely slow but extremely tentative—and this character, which has been present in many of Frey’s works heard this week, marks a major line of divergence in live performance from how they come across in recordings. In my recent CD review, i described the hesitance in Fragile Balance as seeming “not based on caution so much as care”, yet hearing—and, just as importantly, watching—it happen in front of me, caution seemed to be everywhere, implying a tacit anxiety lurking beneath. This extended further to the world première of Grizzana, the continual movement away from its opening luminosity seemingly bespeaking a loss of nerve in the face of terminal timidity. Area of Three, for clarinet, cello and piano, did nothing to bolster the pervading timorous air that by now filled Phipps Hall; my impression here was of trying to have a conversation with an interlocutor permanently on the cusp of nodding off. Again, the more neutral sensibility retained in the recording had become bruised and painful in the space. It’s a curious shift, one that will no doubt send me back again to the recordings for further comparison. The one exception in Ensemble Grizzana’s concert was Ferne Farben, the performance of which proved even more telling live than on disc. What it lost in audible certainty it gained in a heightened atmosphere that came to resemble a séance, each player a medium channelling things from the field recording background beyond.
Philip Thomas‘ recital of three of Frey’s more recent works (all included on the newly-released Another Timbre CD) was very much closer to its recorded counterparts. Extended Circular Music No. 2 and Extended Circular Music No. 9 proved once again to be obtuse if one is looking for a sense of direction beyond that indicated in the title. Each work’s circularity resides not so much in large-scale repetition as in the way every chord sounds simultaneously final—the music could stop at almost any point and it would constitute a plausible end—yet provisional, Frey undermining the otherwise demonstrative cadential moments with an added 6th (in No. 2) and a descending extra line leading to a group of contextually unusual chords (in No. 9). At five minutes, the duration of No. 2 works well, whereas the extension to 20 minutes in No. 9 feels formidably frustrating, a kind of disinterested teasing that eventually, arbitrarily, gets bored and simply stops. Pianist, alone No. 2 begs the question of continuity better, at both the micro level—single lines vs. triads—and also the macro, with respect to its structural cohesion, but the sense of treading water at the expense of trusting forward motion, again spoke from a place of vacillating equivocation. These aren’t in any way complex pieces—more than most, they are what they are—yet the concomitant dependance of these pieces on a superficial listener engagement would seem to render the rewards from doing so extremely limited. These performances suggested that the greatest rewards lie in actually performing them; watching the members of Ensemble Grizzana interact both with each other as well as with the emergent material (some of which is indeterminate, and thereby involves unexpected eventualities) strongly reinforced this idea.
Both in concert and on CD, though, i think I’m concluding at this stage that Jürg Frey’s music is simply a foreign country: they do things differently there. And while it has its interests for a time and perhaps a season, as it has during HCMF, there really is no place like home.