Proms 2013: Helmut Lachenmann – Tanzsuite mit Deutschlandlied (UK Première)

by 5:4

This page is only available to Patreon patrons!

To view this content, you must be a member of Simon's Patreon at £5 or more
Unlock with Patreon
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Leo

I was up in the gallery for this performance, so I had a good view of the people who left during it: I don’t think the piece was actually that warmly received at all. One woman in the circle decided to walk out five minutes before the end: as my friend commented to me, how odd for someone to take thirty minutes to decide they couldn’t abide any more of a thirty-five minute piece.

I found the Lachenmann interesting, but don’t doubt that it suffered from the RAH’s acoustics. Strange that the Southbank Centre haven’t organised a performance of it before now.

Leo

P.S. The ‘extended applause’ was because Lachenmann himself took rather a while to thank lots of people on the stage and no doubt many people in the audience felt it would have been impolite to stop applauding while the composer was on the stage. As soon as he went off, everyone stopped.

[…] on the heels of the large-scale work of Helmut Lachenmann’s a few days ago, tonight’s Proms première was even more ambitious, Thomas Adès‘ […]

kea

according to the score, the deutschlandlied is heard at bar 610 (the very beginning of the 5th section, about 25:30 into the arditti recording) but is probably clearest to make out starting about 0:50 into the galop where it floats above the texture (in very slow note values) in the extreme high register of the piano. the words are written underneath the piano and percussion parts in this section, which actually continues until the very end although the melody subsequently becomes undistinguishable due to being passed to the cymbals.

the way the deutschlandlied takes over the texture seems intended to be a parody of triumphant nationalistic endings (in the same way that a “dance suite” with all the notes taken out can be seen as parodying of a lot of prewar german music, eisler and weill and hindemith and etc), but the methodical fragmentation & deconstruction of everything suggests that something is being criticised—what, exactly, it’s very hard to tell, perhaps a particular cultural or artistic attitude of its time.

BW

So glad that Lachenmann got 67% of the popular vote! If only more voters were on the timbre side of the isle.

6
0
Click here to respond and leave a commentx
()
x